This essay by Elise Silva has now been published in Critical AI at this link https://doi.org/10.1215/2834703X-12689846; the abstract is pasted below. If your institution lacks access to Critical AI please encourage them to subscribe. If you are an independent scholar please write to criticalai@sas.rutgers.edu.
This article argues that AI Overviews (AIO), Google’s default AI-enabled search mechanism at the time of this writing, represents a novel information object. Given this novelty, AIO necessitates a reexamination of how human users evaluate the information they encounter. The article explains the shifting user experience with these systems; specifically, how they synthesize and contextualize information differently than in previous search methods. Furthermore, it discusses how AIO mediates the information-finding experience and presents a “neutral” tone, lending it a false sense of authority. As AI-enabled search continues to evolve beyond legacy page-rank systems and toward the chatbot interface of the new “AI Mode,” it is imperative to trace how this changing information interface affects the broader information environment and the changing human user interactions within it.